The context of Matthew 20:1–16—the parable of the workers in the vineyard—is particularly important for understanding what Jesus is trying to teach.
Just before that, in Matthew 19, Jesus meets the rich young man. The young man asks, “What good thing must I do to have eternal life? ” He walks away sad because he has great wealth. Peter then speaks up: “Look, we have left everything to follow you—so what will be our reward?” (Mt 19:27).
That is precisely the question the parable answers.
Part I
Jesus tells the story of a master who hires workers at different times: some first thing in the morning, others at 9 a.m., noon, 3 p.m., and even at the eleventh hour, around 5 p.m. At the end of the day, however, he gives each one a denarius—that is, a day’s wages.
The first group protests: they worked harder and endured “the burden of the day and the heat.” But the master replies, in essence: I am not taking anything away from what was agreed upon; why do you look with envy upon the kindness I show to others?
The key, then, is less a matter of wage justice than a revelation about the logic of the Kingdom of God. Peter is still thinking in terms of merit: “We have left everything behind—what will we receive?” Jesus shifts the perspective: the Kingdom is first and foremost a gift from God, not a wage proportional to our merits.
That is why the parable is framed by the same idea: “Many who are first will be last, and many who are last will be first” (Mt 19:30), and then: “So the last will be first, and the first will be last” (Mt 20:16).
And the spiritual heart of the text likely lies in the master’s question: “Is your attitude wrong because I am good?” (Matthew 20:15).
In other words, Jesus isn’t just talking about God’s generosity. He’s also revealing our difficulty in accepting that God is just as good to the one who arrives at the last hour as He is to the one who has served Him for a long time. This is where the parable closely resembles that of the Prodigal Son: the problem is not that the Father lacks kindness, but that the older son finds it hard to accept that this kindness is given freely to the other son.
Part II
In fact, the parable may be all the more poignant for those who are convinced they have no problem with God’s goodness.
We can certainly say: “God loves everyone, God forgives everyone, God welcomes everyone.” But Jesus does not ask the workers to acknowledge in theory that the master is good. He places them in a situation where the kindness shown to others touches their own sense of justice, their merit, and their place.
The problem arises when God’s goodness becomes a reality: What if God gave as much to the one who has done so little as to me, who have been faithful? What if He welcomed without reservation someone whose life seems to me far less exemplary? What if my years of service, my sacrifices, and my commitment to the Church gave me no privilege in His sight?
That’s when the master’s words become formidable: “Is your gaze evil because I am good?”
For the faithful Christian, then, the question may not be: “Do you accept that God is good to everyone?” Most would answer yes. Rather, it would be:
“Are you still glad for God’s goodness when it erases the differences to which you secretly attached so much importance?”
And this touches on something very subtle in the Christian life. We may have begun to follow Christ out of a sense of duty, and over the years, we may have accumulated a kind of spiritual capital within ourselves: I have been faithful, I have served, I have endured, I have given a great deal… All of this is true and precious. But gradually, an expectation may arise: surely this should count for more.
Yet Jesus in no way belittles the workers who began at the first hour. They receive exactly what was promised to them. Their trouble begins when they stop focusing on what they have received and start focusing on what others have received.
This may be the most powerful question for Christians who have been committed to their faith for a long time: Do I still experience my faithfulness as a grace, or have I begun to view it as something I’m owed by God?
And there is an even deeper question: Am I capable of rejoicing when someone else receives from God what, by my standards, he does not deserve?
Because at that moment, I might realize that I believed in grace… as long as it didn’t call my comparisons into question.
That is probably why Jesus tells this parable to Peter and the disciples—not to opponents or distant sinners, but specifically to those who have left everything to follow him.
Part III
A disciple who truly hears this parable develops several inner attitudes, but they can be boiled down to a few essential qualities:
- Gratitude: He does not view his faithfulness as a merit to be boasted about, but as a gift. Even having worked “all day” in the vineyard is already a gift.
- Humility: He refrains from measuring his worth before God by comparing himself to others. He knows that he, too, is a recipient of God’s free grace.
- Inner freedom: He does not need to be recognized any more simply because he has given, worked, or suffered more.
- Joy at seeing another person receive a blessing: this is undoubtedly the most demanding standard. He can sincerely rejoice that someone else has received a great deal, even when he feels that he himself has given more.
- Trust: He accepts that God’s goodness goes beyond his own standards of justice. He does not need to understand all of the Master’s decisions in order to believe in His goodness.
- Brotherhood: He stops seeing the other person as a competitor in the vineyard. The one who comes at the last hour takes nothing away from the one who came first.
- Selflessness: He serves God not to earn rewards, but because he loves the Master and his vineyard.
But I would add a quality that is perhaps even more profound: the disciple who understands this parable accepts to be the worker of the last hour himself.
Even after fifty years of faithfulness, he does not stand before God and say, “Look at all I’ve done for you, ” but rather, “Everything I’ve been able to experience with you was already a blessing.”
So the crucial question is no longer, “How much have I given to God?” but rather, “After all these years, am I still amazed that God called me to work in His vineyard?”
Perhaps this is the mark of a mature disciple: faithfulness has not given him a sense of entitlement, but rather a deeper sense of gratitude.
—————————-
